With a remarkable career spanning three seasons, Shaffner amassed an impressive 22 home runs and consistently led the team in RBIs, boasting a stellar .339 batting average. His leadership on the field contributed significantly to the team's success, culminating in three consecutive KIAC and District 32 Tournament titles in 1992, 1993, and 1994. Following his collegiate career, Shaffner transitioned to the professional realm, playing for the Portsmouth Explorers in the Frontier League. Additionally, he embarked on a distinguished coaching career, lending his expertise to various institutions including Union College, University of Rio Grande, IU-Purdue, UVA, and Glenville St. College. Shaffner's coaching journey also encompassed several stints in minor league baseball.

Armond Smith epitomized versatility as a dual-sport athlete at Union, excelling in both track and football. In 2010, his athletic abilities were on full display as he amassed a multitude of accolades across both disciplines. On the football field, Smith's exceptional performance earned him the title of MSC West Division Offensive Player of the Year, fueled by school-record-breaking achievements such as 1,376 rushing yards and 16 touchdowns. Notably, he set the bar high with a remarkable 312-yard rushing feat and a record-breaking 5 touchdowns in a single game against Bethel University. Furthermore, Smith's stellar contributions earned him the distinction of being named NAIA Player of the Week. 

In track and field, he continued to shine, securing recognition as a 2010 NAIA All-American in three outdoor events, including a commendable 5th place finish in the 200-meter dash. Smith's crowning achievements came in the form of NAIA National Championships, where he triumphed in the 110-meter hurdles and the 4 x 100 relay alongside teammates Marekus Smith, James Fowler, and Santraz Andrews. His dominance extended to setting numerous school records across both indoor and outdoor track events, including the 55m and 60m hurdles indoors, and the 110m and 400m hurdles, as well as the 4 x 100 relay outdoors. 

Rentat Cabral made history for the women's swimming program at Union College. In that year, she secured the title of 2012 NAIA National Champion in the 100 Freestyle, becoming the program's first-ever national champion. Renata also earned recognition as a 2012 NAIA All-American in both the 50 Freestyle and 100 Freestyle events, further solidifying her legacy. Her remarkable achievements extend to holding six program records, showcasing her exceptional talent and dedication to the sport. Additionally, Renata played a pivotal role in the women's swimming team's success, contributing to their highest NAIA National Tournament Finish in program history, securing the impressive ranking of #7 in 2012.

Amanda McKay was a standout cyclist at Union from 2002 to 2006, leaving an indelible mark on the program. Throughout her collegiate career, McKay showcased her exceptional talent and determination by winning three Individual National Championships. In 2002, she claimed victory in the Women’s Omnium event, followed by another triumph in the same category in 2003. McKay's success culminated in 2006 when she clinched the Women’s Short Track National Championship, solidifying her status as one of the most accomplished cyclists in Union's history.

Wesley Lamberson made a significant impact as a cyclist at Union from 2010 to 2013, showcasing his exceptional talent and contributing to the program's success. During his collegiate career, Lamberson achieved remarkable feats by winning two Individual National Championships. In 2012, he emerged victorious in the Men’s Omnium event, followed by another triumph in the same category in 2013. Additionally, Lamberson played a pivotal role in the 2011 cycling team, which secured the program's second NCAA National Championship in history. Furthermore, the team also clinched the title of Southeast Collegiate Conference Champions.